American Home Products v. Adriatic Ins. Co

In American Home Products v. Adriatic Ins. Co., 286 N.J. Super. 24, 668 A.2d 67 (App. Div. 1995), the Court placed the initial burden on the moving party to establish that: (1) there is a first-filed action in another state; (2) both cases involve the same parties, the same claims and the same legal issues; (3) the plaintiff will have the opportunity for adequate relief in the prior jurisdiction. Id. at 37, 668 A.2d 67. Once these requisites have been established, the moving party enjoys a "clear entitlement to comity-stay relief" and the burden falls upon the plaintiff to demonstrate that "special equities" exist that are sufficiently compelling to permit the action to proceed. Ibid.