Hardy Plumbing, Heating & A.C. v. Menu

In Hardy Plumbing, Heating & A.C. v. Menu (65 AD3d 609 [2009] the Appellate Division reversed an order of this court (Pines, J.) and granted the homeowner's motion for summary judgment dismissing the contractors' breach of contract counterclaim based on the contractors' failure to obtain a home improvement contractor's license from the Town of East Hampton. In so doing, however, the Appellate Division did not identify the home improvements on which it found the counterclaim was based, except to refer to them as "certain home improvements."