Borough of Bedford v. Department of Environmental Protection

In Borough of Bedford v. Department of Environmental Protection, 972 A.2d 53, 62 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2009), various municipalities that operated wastewater and sewage treatment plants filed a petition for review challenging a Compliance Plan issued by the Department of Environmental Protection (DEP). The municipalities argued that the Plan was invalid as an unpromulgated regulation. DEP filed a motion for summary relief. The Court denied the motion, concluding that the issue of whether the Plan was a regulation or a statement of policy could not be determined by reviewing its component documents alone. Bedford, 972 A.2d at 60-61, 68. The Court held that further discovery was needed on the issue of how the Plan actually functioned. Id. at 67-68.