Red Giant Oil Co. v. Lawlor

In Red Giant Oil Co. v. Lawlor, 528 N.W.2d 524, 532-33 (Iowa 1995), the court rejected the Freeman v. Schmidt Real Estate & Ins., Inc., 755 F.2d 135 (8th Cir. 1985) court's conclusion and held a covenant not to execute is merely an agreement rather than a release, the underlying tort liability remains, a breach of contract action is available if the injured party seeks to collect the confessed judgment, and the stipulated judgment does not eliminate the fact of damages. Consequently, the court ruled, because there remained outstanding liability against the insured who had confessed judgment in favor of the injured party, there was "potential damage" caused by an insurance agent's failure to procure the correct coverage, and the action against the agent was viable if there was no insurance coverage. Id. at 533.